Noel Tata's communications set conditions for tense Tata Sons board meeting next week
Read more
Business Standard
business-standard.com

Noel Tata's communications set conditions for tense Tata Sons board meeting next week

Noel Tata, Non-Executive Director of Tata Sons and Chairman of Tata Trusts, has once again demanded audio and video recordings of the contentious managing company meeting held on September 17, 2026. He also questioned the legality of Chandrasekaran's reappointment and raised issues regarding alleged conflicts of interest involving Non-Executive Director Venugopal Srinivasan.

In a new letter dated November 20, addressed to company secretary Suprakash Mukhopadhyay and copied to all directors, including Chairman Chandrasekaran, Noel expressed dissatisfaction with the company's response to his previous requests for recordings and other documents.

This latest communication arrived shortly before the next Tata Sons board meeting scheduled for November 26, where the minutes of the September 17 meeting are expected to be approved.

Noel noted that out of the requests made in his letter of October 26, 2026, the company provided only two documents: an interest notification from April 10, 2025, and the agenda with unsigned minutes of the Nomination and Remuneration Committee. The remaining requests were either rejected or ignored.

He pointed out that the previous response from the company secretary confirmed the existence of the audio and video recording of the September 17 meeting. However, the secretary had previously stated that the recording was intended to assist in preparing the draft minutes, that providing such recordings was not standard company practice, and that they were not obligated to be stored or transferred to anyone, including directors.

Noel deemed this position unacceptable. He explained that his request was not based on practice but on the fact that the draft minutes were being challenged on the most crucial issue discussed at the meeting, and that the recording was the sole evidence of what was said that was not recorded by anyone else.

He asserted that a director has the right to examine the company's books and records, regardless of whether they are kept in physical or electronic form, and that neither law nor the Articles of Association grant Tata Sons the right to withhold the recording of a meeting attended by a director.

Noel demanded that the company confirm that the complete audio and video recording of the September 17 meeting exists in original and unedited form, along with metadata. He also requested information on the storage location of the recording, who is responsible for its safekeeping, and who had access to it since September 17. He insisted that the company confirm the preservation of the recording until all issues concerning the meeting are resolved.

If any part of the recording was deleted, edited, or overwritten, Noel requested details on the time the action took place, who performed it, and under whose instructions. The letter included a warning that Tata Sons knew about the dispute over the minutes starting September 18 and needed the recording.

He stated that any deletion or alteration after that date would constitute deliberate destruction of evidence, and everyone responsible would bear personal liability. Noel proposed reviewing the recording at Bombay House accompanied by a consultant and in the presence of Mukhopadhyay. Furthermore, he requested the preparation of a transcript by an independent stenographer at his own expense by November 25.

Noel also questioned the proper documentation of his dissent at the September 17 meeting. He requested information on when the minutes were entered into the minutes book and who signed them. He pointed out that minutes should be entered within 30 days of the meeting, and he had yet to receive the final signed version.

Referring to item 9 of the meeting agenda, concerning the proposed reappointment of Chandrasekaran as Executive Chairman, Noel objected that Chandrasekaran had an interest in the matter and should not participate in the approval or signing of the minutes pertaining to him. He emphasized that since Chandrasekaran had an interest in this item, he could not properly decide what should be in the minutes or sign them as an accurate record against his objection.

Noel also questioned the process of putting forward the resolution for Chandrasekaran's reappointment for another five-year term. He argued that the resolution was presented without prior notice and based on a recommendation that had not yet been given by the Nomination and Remuneration Committee (NRC).

He reminded that the obligation under Section 117 is to submit the adopted resolution, not a resolution that was not adopted. He also disputed the interpretation of Articles 118 and 121 of the company's Articles.

In Noel's view, Article 121 requires a positive vote of the majority of directors appointed under Article 104B who were present at the meeting. He reported that there were two such directors, and one voted against the resolution. He challenged the company's reliance on the chairman's casting vote, arguing that Article 121 provides for a casting vote only in case of a tie of the entire board, and does not allow him to override the voting requirement applicable to the two directors appointed under Article 104B.

The letter also raised questions about an alleged conflict of interest involving Chandrasekaran's family and Venugopal Srinivasan, Non-Executive Director of Tata Sons and Chairman of TVS Group. Noel noted that the disclosures available to the Tata Sons board indicated that Chandrasekaran's wife and son are partners in Hanno Infra LLP, as well as directors and members of Hanno One Warehousing Private Limited. However, he claimed that the disclosures did not mention any business relationship with TVS Motor Company.

This issue gains significance against the backdrop of reports of commercial transactions between TVS Motor and Hanno One, a structure linked to Chandrasekaran's family. Noel questioned whether Srinivasan could objectively assess Chandrasekaran's performance, recommend his remuneration, and vote for his reappointment while the company he leads and his family had ongoing commercial dealings with the company owned by the Executive Chairman's wife and son.

He pointed out that the minutes provided to him showed that Srinivasan participated in the committee that assessed Chandrasekaran's performance and recommended his remuneration on June 12, 2026, and then decided on September 3 to ask him to remain chairman. Noel also referred to the Tata Code of Conduct, stating that it requires disclosure if relationships could, upon objective assessment, raise concerns about a potential conflict of interest.

Tata Sons had previously dismissed allegations of conflict of interest between the two families, asserting that appropriate disclosures had been made. The latest letter demands further clarification on this matter.

The proposed listing of Tata Sons remains another major point of contention between Noel and the company's management. In his latest communication, Noel referenced the Reserve Bank of India's letter of November 16 requesting Tata Sons to comply with applicable regulatory requirements, including listing.

He noted that the RBI's response followed a letter from Tata Sons dated October 6, which was not presented to or shown to the board before being sent. Noel requested a copy of the October 6 letter, details on who approved it, and whether it was shown to any director before dispatch. He also wants to know what exactly Tata Sons informed the RBI about the September 17 board discussions regarding listing. He mentioned that the company should have sought guidance from the RBI on his alternative proposal for restructuring aimed at keeping Tata Sons a private company.

In conclusion, Noel urged Tata Sons not to take any steps towards listing, including appointing consultants or intermediaries, until the board of directors considers the alternative proposal to maintain the company's private status. He requested that this proposal be circulated along with the agenda for the November 26 board meeting and asked the company to seek clarification from the RBI on the specific restructuring proposal.

The latest letter exacerbates the disagreements between Tata Trusts and Tata Sons regarding the ownership structure of the managing company, regulatory obligations, and leadership succession. The November 26 board meeting is anticipated to be a crucial forum for resolving contentious minutes and issues related to Chandrasekaran's reappointment and the proposed listing.

Similar stories

Noel Tata requested records of Tata Sons board meetings
Read more
yourstory.com

Noel Tata requested records of Tata Sons board meetings

The Chairman of Tata Trusts, Noel Tata, again approached Tata Sons on Friday requesting audio and video recordings of the board meeting of the holding company for all Tata Group entities, which took place on September 17.

In a letter addressed to Tata Sons companion Supraksha Mukhopadhyay, Noel stated his right as a board member to demand these recordings. He also requested the materials of the Nomination and Remuneration Committee (NRC) of the board, which N. Chandrasekaran had asked to reconsider his decision to decline reappointment as Chairman of Tata Sons, according to sources.

It is reported that the NRC held a meeting on September 3 and decided to require Chandrasekaran to reconsider his refusal to be nominated for reappointment.

In his appeal, Noel pointed out that Venu Srinivasan, the nominee director of Tata Trusts on the Tata Sons board, should have abstained from discussing the matter of reappointment due to a conflict of interest.

Sources indicated that the letter touched upon transactions between the company headed by Srinivasan and another company owned by Chandrasekaran's son, which they believe constitutes a conflict of interest.

According to media reports, business operations took place between Hanno Warehousing, managed by members of the Chandrasekaran family, and TVS Group. Previously, Tata Sons denied any conflict of interest in this matter, asserting that everything had been duly disclosed.

Earlier this month, Tata Sons had refused Noel access to these recordings. Noel's letter was sent on Friday evening, several hours after the meeting of two Tata Trusts, where decisions were made regarding the provision of grants exceeding 250 crore rupees.

According to sources, all resolutions at the meetings of Sir Dorabji Tata Trust and Tata Education and Development Trust were passed unanimously, and issues outside the agenda were not discussed.

Srinivasan and Vijay Singh, who opposed Noel, are trustees of SDTT. The next Tata Sons board meeting is scheduled for November 26.

Jimmy Tata opposes Noel Tata, arguing that the listing of Tata Sons will end the culture of secrecy
Read more
business-standard.com

Jimmy Tata opposes Noel Tata, arguing that the listing of Tata Sons will end the culture of secrecy

Jimmy Tata, the senior trustee of Tata Trusts and younger brother of former chairman Ratan Tata, has publicly commented for the first time on the internal dispute within the Tata group. The 86-year-old Jimmy, who lives in a modest apartment in Pune and is often described as reserved, expressed concern over the 'unnatural, dictatorial veto powers' granted to the Chairman of Tata Trusts, which is the largest shareholder in Tata Sons, holding a 66% stake.

Jimmy, who owns approximately 0.81 percent of Tata Sons shares, supported the listing of Tata Sons on the stock exchange, which is at the center of the biggest corporate battle of the time. According to him, the listing would eliminate the pervasive culture of secrecy, introduce legislative accountability, and require a review of the burdensome Articles of Association (AoA) to restore the separation between business operations and charitable trusts that existed before 1989. He called the listing a critical step.

Noel Tata, Chairman of Tata Trusts and a nominated director of the Tata Sons board, had previously stated multiple times his disagreement with the listing of Tata Sons at a media event on Saturday. He argued that 'the listing would change Tata's approach, placing profit above philanthropy.' Noel, who holds 1 percent of Tata Sons shares, held this view.

Considering recent events in the group, Jimmy reportedly stated that the listing of Tata Sons, required by the Reserve Bank of India (RBI), is 'even more critical.' He noted that Tata Sons previously 'benefited immensely when Tata Consultancy Services was listed under Ratan Tata,' and added that 'any proposal or move by Noel Tata to split Tata Sons into smaller entities to avoid RBI listing thresholds is deeply detrimental and contrary to the interests of the public and shareholders, being made solely to maintain secrecy, evade scrutiny, and preserve unchecked personal power.'

He also stated that the RBI must ensure strict adherence to listing timelines without delays and guarantee that the group's division will not be permitted. Furthermore, he called for government and Charity Commissioner intervention 'to protect the original objectives of the trusts for the people of India.'

Beyond this dispute regarding N. Chandrasekaran's reappointment for a third term as Executive Chairman of Tata Sons, Jimmy was quoted saying: 'JRD Tata valued and nurtured his key star performers (including Sumant Mulgankar, Darbari Seth, Xerxes Desai, and Rusi Modi), whereas the current management does not support its proven star performers.' He added that 'Noel tried to arbitrarily block him using onerous veto provisions in the amended AoA, without providing any justification or accountability,' despite the 'overwhelming support' from the Tata Sons board and the 'unanimous decision' by Tata Trusts in favor of Chandrasekaran's third term. Jimmy mentioned 'significant dividend payouts' from Tata companies to shareholders, including Tata Sons, in support of Chandrasekaran.

At the Tata Sons board meeting on September 17, 2026, Noel voted against Chandrasekaran's third term and opposed the listing proposal. Subsequently, Noel proposed restructuring Tata Sons to remain a private company.

Responding to questions related to the current situation in Tata Trusts and other widely reported events in the group, Jimmy stated that 'the central driver of this issue is the drastic change in the Articles around 2013–2014. Historically, prior to 1989, the Articles strictly separated charitable trusts from Tata Sons commercial operations, ensuring that the trusts had no operational management role.' He added that subsequent amendments 'fundamentally disrupted this balance by granting the Chairman of Tata Trusts unnatural, dictatorial veto powers and the right to appoint directors, thereby undermining the collective authority of the rest of the board.'

Why is the Tata family in the spotlight?

Jimmy, trustee of the Sir Ratan Tata Trust (SRTT)—a key shareholder trust—has raised the issue since 1989 that family members occupy positions on the boards of Tata Trusts. He stated that 'recently, what is happening is that the trusts are being filled with members of the current Chairman of Tata Trusts' family, thereby ensuring a certain degree of control over Tata Sons that was never the intention of the founders.' Jimmy asserted that 'it is completely inappropriate for more than one family member to hold a position in this trust; it effectively grants ownership rights to a significant portion of the trusts in Tata Sons without any compensation.' In Jimmy's view, such an arrangement is 'unsustainable and represents a hidden takeover of Tata Sons.'

He emphasized that trustees should be custodians of public trusts that can never be dissolved, unlike private family trusts, citing 'independent luminaries' such as Nani Palkhivala, Gautam Sarabhai, Homi Sethna, and Homi Bhabha, who were previous trustees.

The SRTT, which was frozen by the Maharashtra Charity Commissioner earlier this year due to perpetual trustee rules, allows only a quarter of the total board composition to be permanent or lifetime trustees under the amended law. Currently, SRTT has three permanent trustees—Noel Tata, who is Ratan Tata's half-brother and Jimmy Tata's brother; Jehangir H.S. Jehangir, an industrialist and philanthropist; and Jimmy N Tata. The term of the fourth trustee in SRTT, Venu Srinivasan, expires in December 2026 unless extended. With a four-trustee composition, only one can be a permanent member.

Although Jimmy is not part of another key shareholder trust—the Sir Dorabji Tata Trust (SDTT)—he is also a trustee of several other smaller charitable trusts.

What is the dispute over trustee terms?

Criticizing the lack of uniformity in decisions, including the extension of terms in Tata Trusts, Jimmy stated that introducing a time limit on the tenure of certain trustees while freeing others 'compromised the independence of the trustees and concentrated power, allowing trustees who disagreed to be marginalized or removed.' Citing Venu Srinivasan as an example, Jimmy said he was attacked because he 'opposed the inclusion of Noel's son in SRTT.' Neville Tata, Noel Tata's son, is a trustee of SDTT but not SRTT. Neville and his sisters, Lia and Maya, are also on the boards of some other trusts.

Jimmy, who generally avoids public appearances, including Tata Trusts meetings, attended the funeral of his elder brother Ratan Tata in Mumbai on October 10, 2024.

Popular