As discussions on land reform continue, experts and land recipients are questioning how to keep the land profitable and ensure its successful use. Brian Whittaker and Mazwi Mkhulisi from the non-profit organization Vumelana Advisory Fund argue that effective management and community-private partnerships (CPPs) can attract investment, create jobs, and generate income for communities involved in land reform.
Whittaker and Mkhulisi provide examples from CPP cases in the provinces of Mpumalanga, Eastern Cape, North West, and Limpopo, demonstrating restored land parcels ranging from 639 to 26,000 hectares.
The CPP model, which Vumelana began implementing over ten years ago, links land reform beneficiary communities, organized as Community Property Associations (CPAs), with private investors. The goal of this model is to make the restored land productive, economically viable, and sustainable.
Typically, communities provide the land and receive in return rental income, employment opportunities, and dividends, while private partners provide capital and expertise. This model aims to address the problem of insufficient post-settlement support. The return of land to communities is only part of land reform; without investment, technical expertise, market access, and effective management, restored land becomes unproductive, depriving beneficiaries of the ability to develop a sustainable livelihood.
Whittaker emphasizes that partnerships accompanied by proper guarantees, accountability mechanisms, and community participation have contributed to improved living conditions and the creation of economic opportunities. He notes that in the studied cases, the restored lands ranged from 639 to 26,000 hectares, and commercial partners ranged from family businesses to global corporations worth billions of rand. Partnerships included long-term leases of 23 to 49 years, with most including stock options allowing communities to gain an equity stake.
Vumelana Advisory Fund stated in a release that in agricultural projects, assets remained with the community landowners, while tourism agreements stipulated the return of assets to the communities at the end of the lease term.
According to the organization's data, the rent received by CPAs ranged from 750,000 to several million rand annually, with dividends and fees ranging from 800,000 to 12.2 million rand yearly. Wages and salaries accounted for over 80% of the benefit in some cases. Communities also benefited from training, skills development, and procurement opportunities.
Studies showed that the income of community members increased by 30%–90% compared to those not involved in the projects. Furthermore, this fostered financial inclusion: beneficiaries gained better access to bank accounts and credit facilities, and improved access to education and skills, reducing dependence on social welfare and the need to pull children out of school or skip meals due to lack of funds, as noted by Vumelana Advisory Fund.
Deal consultants play a critical role in facilitating these partnerships by providing independent advice and negotiating fair agreements that protect the interests of both parties and ensure mutual benefit. Without the support of independent deal consultants, communities risk entering into unfavorable arrangements, which could undermine the sustainability of these partnerships. If partnerships collapse, the consequences extend beyond the immediate parties, leading to unproductive land, unemployment, and renewed demands for state support.
Mkhulisi noted that in one instance, engaging an independent deal consultant helped a community secure 70 million rand in new investment, increase rental income by 80 million rand over the lease term, and raise its ownership stake from 40% to 50%, while the number of jobs increased from 150 to 250. In another case, a community that revised the agreement without independent consultation lost significant contractual rights previously secured with the consultant's help.
Mkhulisi stressed that while independent deal advice is necessary for the success of CPPs, the financial reality of land reform makes it difficult for private consultants to provide these services on a commercial basis. Since about a third of deals result in successful transactions that can cover costs, there is a funding gap that is best filled through government funding. Whittaker stated that while commercial partnerships are not a panacea for land reform problems, Vumelana's experience shows they offer a practical path to solving the post-settlement dilemma. The government can help make these partnerships more accessible by providing public funding for independent deal consultant services so that communities do not have to negotiate alone.


