VHP demands ban on film 'Ramayana' due to distorted portrayal of Rama and glorification of Ravana
Read more
Aaj Tak
www.aajtak.in

VHP demands ban on film 'Ramayana' due to distorted portrayal of Rama and glorification of Ravana

A controversy has arisen surrounding the film 'Ramayana,' starring Ranbir Kapoor and Yash, as the public organization alleges that the movie distorts the narrative of Lord Rama and excessively glorifies Ravana. Consequently, VHP has demanded an immediate halt to screenings and the annulment of its certificate.

The Central Secretary of VHP, Bajrang Bagda, accused the filmmakers of incorrectly depicting Lord Rama and elevating Ravana. He stated that many crucial plotlines from the epic written by Maharishi Valmiki were either omitted or altered, causing indignation among Hindu devotees.

Bajrang Bagda also noted that the film fails to adequately address significant episodes such as the rescue of Ahilya, the friendship between Lord Rama and King Nishada Gaha, and the devotion of Kevata. Furthermore, he argued that instead of portraying Lord Rama's battle against demons as a campaign against forces obstructing the religious practices of sages, the film attempts to present it as a personal conflict arising from the abduction of a wife.

VHP believes that the picture tries to portray Ravana as a savior of the oppressed and helpless, while ignoring his character, his treatment of women, and his feelings for Goddess Parvati. The International President of VHP, Alok Kumar, also expressed dissatisfaction with the film 'Ramayana.' He stated that after watching the movie, he is convinced that changes were made to the Ramakatha and the events of Lord Rama's life that contradict established ideals.

Alok Kumar added that these changes are not merely creative decisions to enhance drama or cinematic effect; they appear to be deliberate attempts to establish a false narrative. He pointed out that the film portrays Ravana with sympathy, disregarding his character, his behavior towards women, and his views on Goddess Parvati. According to Alok Kumar, Sita's abduction is presented as revenge for the mutilation of Ravana's sister, and Ravana is depicted as a protector of the downtrodden, helpless, and lower castes.

VHP insists that 'Ramayana' is not just a religious story but a sacred text that teaches society morality, ideals, and life values. Therefore, in the organization's view, altering the plots and characters in such a work goes beyond the creative freedom of filmmakers. This is why VHP demands the revocation of the certificate and the immediate cessation of screenings.

Despite the controversy, the film 'Ramayana,' released 16 days ago, has surpassed the mark of 1500 crore in global box office and is soon expected to reach 1600 crore. This film is the first part, created with a budget of 2000 crore. The next part will be released in December 2028 and will also cost 2000 crore.

Similar stories

According to Valmiki's Ramayana, Ravana's motivation for revenge against Rama was different from what was previously thought
Read more
www.aajtak.in

According to Valmiki's Ramayana, Ravana's motivation for revenge against Rama was different from what was previously thought

The film 'Ramayana' by Nitesh Tiwari is generating significant interest. In this picture, Ranbir Kapoor played the role of Lord Rama, and Yash played the role of the King of Lanka, Ravana. It is widely known that in the stories of Ramayana, after Lakshmana cut off Shurpanakha's nose, Ravana became enraged and abducted Sita, and then he was defeated by Rama. The recently released 'Ramayana' also follows this plot. However, there are some differences in the narrative in Valmiki's Ramayana.

Shurpanakha's husband, Vidushaka, died at the hands of Dashanan. After his death, Shurpanakha was completely alone. Meanwhile, Lord Rama went into fourteen years of exile with his wife Sita and brother Lakshmana, living in Panchavati.

While staying in Panchavati, Shurpanakha noticed Lord Rama and was charmed by him. Shurpanakha proposed marriage to Rama, but Shri Rama was bound by a promise and could not think of any woman other than his beloved Sita, so he politely refused her.

However, Shurpanakha, belonging to the Asura clan, could not accept this refusal; her love suddenly turned into arrogance. Now she wanted to obtain Rama at any cost. She planned to eliminate Sita, who stood between her and Rama. When Lakshmana learned of this intention, he first gave Shurpanakha a stern warning. But since she persisted in her desire, Lakshmana cut off her nose with his sword.

This is where the story of Valmiki's Ramayana differs from other versions. According to Valmiki's Ramayana, after Lakshmana cut off her nose, Shurpanakha sought help not from Ravana, but from her brother Hara in Janasthana (a place that is now somewhere in Nashik). Then Hara swore revenge on Rama on behalf of his sister and started the war. His entire army attacked Rama and Lakshmana, but the Asuras could not withstand Rama's divine powers. Rama destroyed Hara's entire army, and Hara himself died in this battle.

After this, a messenger from Hara's army, being a powerful demon, reached the King of Lanka, Ravana, and informed him of the battle's outcome. He reported that Rama had destroyed Hara and his entire army. Then Ravana decided to take revenge on Rama for the death of Hara and his army. It is said that up to this point, Ravana did not know about Shurpanakha's affair.

Moreover, one demon from Hara's army told Ravana that Rama was extremely powerful, and defeating him in battle was very difficult. However, if Rama's wife, Sita, could be captured somehow, he would weaken, and it would be easier to overcome him. For this reason, Ravana first kidnapped Sita, and then the fierce battle between Rama and Ravana ensued, resulting in Dashanan's death.

Hindu organizations protest film 'Ramayana' over plot changes
Read more
www.aajtak.in

Hindu organizations protest film 'Ramayana' over plot changes

The release of the film 'Ramayana' has sparked significant controversy, as Hindu organizations accuse the creators of altering the original narrative from Valmiki's epic. These groups have called for a boycott of the film and demanded an official response from the producers.

In Mumbai, several Hindu organizations lodged complaints against the creators, asserting that they distorted the original story described in Valmiki's Ramayana. They urged the public to refrain from watching the film and expressed disagreement with the release of its second part.

At a press conference held on November 17 in Mumbai, representatives of these organizations raised concerns regarding several scenes. They stated that the portrayals of Lord Shri Rama, Mother Sita, Lakshmana, and Ravana in the film do not align with how they are depicted in Valmiki's Ramayana.

Sunil Ghanawat, coordinator for Maharashtra and Chhattisgarh of the Hindu Janagriti Samiti, spoke out against the film, arguing that under the guise of creative freedom, the original spirit of the Ramayana is being violated. He also called on Hindus to boycott the movie.

The primary grievance of the organizations concerns the depiction of Ravana. They claim that in the film, Ravana is portrayed as a protector of the oppressed and a king who grants golden homes to the poor, which contradicts the established narrative of the Ramayana.

The disputes are not limited to Ravana's portrayal. The organizations also objected to certain scenes, including the killing of Vidhyatva, Shurpanakha's husband, as shown in the film. Furthermore, questions were raised about scenes where Shri Rama and Lakshmana flee from Ravana's army, as well as scenes depicting Mother Sita fighting demons.

The organizations insist that such events do not appear in Valmiki's Ramayana in this form. They emphasize that when creating a film based on religious scripture, it is crucial to adhere to the original plot and the dignity of the characters.

The Hindu organizations have also submitted their comments to the Central Board of Film Certification (Censor Board). Sunil Ghanawat accused the Censor Board of being overly vigilant regarding the sentiments of other religions but insufficiently sensitive to the religious themes of Hinduism. He demanded that Censor Board members thoroughly study relevant religious texts before issuing certificates for films based on sacred scriptures and protested the release of the film's second part.

Sanatan Sanstha also expressed its dissatisfaction. An organization representative, Abhay Vartak, noted the changes in the film, stating that the creators must present events in accordance with what is described in the original text. In his view, the altered scenes are unacceptable.

Currently, religious and cultural debates surrounding the film 'Ramayana' have intensified. While Hindu organizations are protesting the alleged changes, the filmmakers' stance on the matter has yet to be announced. Despite attempts to contact the creators through India Today/Aajtak, no response was received at the time of writing.

Actor Nitish Bhardwaj expresses dissatisfaction with the film 'Ramayana', stating he retracts his positive reviews
Read more
www.aajtak.in

Actor Nitish Bhardwaj expresses dissatisfaction with the film 'Ramayana', stating he retracts his positive reviews

Nitish Bhardwaj, an actor who played Lord Krishna in B.R. Chopra's television series 'Mahabharata', watched the film 'Ramayana' featuring Ranbir Kapoor and Yash, and expressed strong disappointment with it. He stated that there is nothing good to be said about this adaptation.

He shared his opinion in a long social media post, noting that the film does not meet the standard of Indian cinema on the international stage. Bhardwaj accused the filmmakers of distorting the history, heritage, and spiritual values of India.

In his Instagram post, Nitish emphasized that 'Ramayana' is not just a story but an integral part of India's civilization and spiritual consciousness. He also raised objections to how the character of Ravana was portrayed in the film. In his view, the depiction of Ravana alters the original lesson and moral principles of the 'Ramayana.'

The actor wrote that presenting Ravana as extremely generous, a proponent of social justice, and an impartial person changes the moral foundation of the 'Ramayana', which calls into question the true purpose of embodying a divine avatar. He also clarified that his initial praise for the trailer did not match his impressions after watching the entire film.

Expressing his disappointment, he stated that he could not find a single positive aspect in the movie. He noted that magnificent visual effects (VFX) cannot replace the value, philosophical depth, and spiritual essence of this epic. Bhardwaj insisted that India's cultural heritage must be presented to the world properly, and questioned whether such a film has the right to represent India on the international scene.

He concluded: 'In my opinion, this film is not worthy of representing Indian cinema internationally because it distorts India's history, heritage, and core spiritual values.'

It should be noted that previously Nitish Bhardwaj had spoken in support of the film, suggesting that 'Ramayana' should receive an 'Oscar' as the best international film. However, he is now retracting his previous statements. Many people have supported his viewpoint. It remains to be seen how this will affect the box office collection of 'Ramayana.'

Regarding collections, the film has reached the mark of 700 crore worldwide. On Monday, it set a significant record for collections in India, and on Tuesday, being a working day, the film also showed good results. Now it remains to be seen if it can reach the planned budget of 2000 crore.

Popular