Central Asia Identifies New Environmental Risks Associated with Antimicrobial Resistance
Read more
UzDaily
uzdaily.uz

Central Asia Identifies New Environmental Risks Associated with Antimicrobial Resistance

Antimicrobial resistance (AMR) is becoming a serious problem for both public health and the environment in Central Asia. The spread of resistant microorganisms can occur through wastewater, agricultural runoff, and transboundary rivers.

Global experience shows that bacterial resistance to antibiotics led to approximately 1.14 million deaths in 2021. Projections indicate that by 2050, annual deaths directly linked to this issue could reach 1.91 million.

Experts raised questions about the pathways of antimicrobial-resistant microorganisms at an international conference on AMR held in Astana on November 19. Oksana Kravtsova, coordinator of the 'One Health' project at the Central Asian Regional Environmental Centre (CAREC), addressed this issue.

Scale of the Problem: Millions of Deaths and Rising Economic Costs

The scope of the problem is illustrated by the Global Burden of Bacterial Antimicrobial Resistance 1990–2021 study, published in The Lancet in 2024. According to data presented at the conference, approximately 1.14 million deaths worldwide in 2021 were directly linked to bacterial resistance to antimicrobials. A broader figure of 4.71 million deaths covers cases where AMR was associated with mortality but was not necessarily the direct cause.

Under the study's baseline scenario, bacterial AMR could potentially cause a cumulative 39.1 million deaths between 2025 and 2050. By 2050, annual deaths from bacterial antibiotic resistance could reach 1.91 million, and the total number of deaths related to resistance could rise to 8.22 million. It is important to note that these figures are global and do not reflect mortality rates for Uzbekistan or Central Asia.

In addition to the threat to life, AMR also entails economic consequences. Drug-resistant infections may require longer treatment, additional diagnostic tests, expensive medications, and prolonged hospitalization. This places an extra burden on healthcare systems, increases patient costs, and leads to economic losses due to temporary disability and reduced labor productivity. Thus, the problem extends beyond medicine and affects economic stability and the efficiency of public spending.

Amu Darya and Syr Darya as Potential Pathways for Resistant Microorganisms

The CAREC presentation focused on the environmental pathways through which resistant microorganisms and antimicrobial resistance genes can accumulate and circulate. These pathways include municipal and hospital wastewater, sewage treatment plants, rivers, water bodies, livestock complexes, agricultural soils, and irrigation systems.

Special attention was paid to the transboundary river basins of Central Asia, including the Amu Darya, Syr Darya, and Ili rivers. These rivers connect territories of several countries, and their use in agriculture, animal husbandry, and domestic purposes creates potential routes for microbial contamination to move. However, the presence of such pathways does not mean that specific sections of the Amu Darya or Syr Darya are already recognized as a threat to public health; systematic laboratory monitoring is required for such conclusions.

This issue is particularly relevant for Uzbekistan due to the dependence of agriculture on irrigation and the strategic importance of transboundary water resources.

Wastewater and Livestock: Potential Sources of Resistance

Wastewater is one of the possible sources of resistant bacteria. Municipal and medical wastewater can contain both antibiotic-resistant bacteria and resistance genes. The effectiveness of sewage treatment plants and the subsequent use of treated water play a crucial role in limiting its entry into the environment.

Additional risks are associated with livestock farming. Manure, farm wastewater, and the use of antibacterial drugs in veterinary medicine can contribute to the entry of resistant microorganisms and genetic material into soil and water bodies. The presentation also highlighted wildlife, glaciers, and meltwater as potential elements in the ecological cycle of resistance genes, although the degree of contribution of each of these factors to the problem in Central Asia still needs to be determined.

How Climate Change Can Intensify Risks

Climate change can affect the survival and spread conditions of microorganisms. In particular, rising water temperatures can create conditions favorable for the horizontal transfer of resistance genes between bacteria. The presentation cited results from a laboratory study published in the Journal of Hazardous Materials in 2024: when water temperature increased from 5 to 30 degrees Celsius, the frequency of antimicrobial resistance gene transfer in the studied experimental system increased by approximately 30 times. However, this figure cannot be directly applied to natural ecosystems in Central Asia or used to predict increases in morbidity and mortality.

Extreme weather events are also a risk factor. During heavy rains and floods, pollutants can be washed from agricultural fields and farms into surface waters. Droughts and water scarcity, in turn, increase the significance of water reuse, effective purification, and adherence to sanitary standards. Therefore, climate change can not only exacerbate existing environmental risks but also alter the pathways through which resistant microorganisms affect humans and animals. Nevertheless, the key drivers of AMR remain the use of antimicrobials, sanitation conditions, and access to effective treatment.

Central Asia's Main Challenge: Lack of Comparable Data

According to CAREC, one of the main obstacles to a comprehensive risk assessment is the lack of comparable data. Information on AMR is collected by various institutions and covers many areas: healthcare, veterinary medicine, environment, and climate monitoring. Clinical data help assess the resistance of infectious disease pathogens, as well as diagnostic and treatment outcomes. Veterinary data concerns the use of antibacterial drugs and animal monitoring results. Environmental studies allow for the detection of resistant microorganisms and resistance genes in water, soil, and wastewater. Climate monitoring provides information on temperature, precipitation, floods, and hydrological conditions.

However, establishing links between these processes remains a complex task without harmonized indicators, common data quality standards, and joint analysis. This is especially important for the Amu Darya basin, as water use is transboundary and requires coordination of environmental and sanitary measures.

Five Priority Research Areas for Central Asia

Within the 'One Health' approach, CAREC has identified five promising areas for regional research. The first area involves studying seasonal correlations between temperature, flooding, and AMR indicators. The second focuses on identifying the pathways of resistant microorganism dissemination through water, soil, livestock complexes, and settlements. The third direction involves comparing microorganisms found in patients, animals, and the environment. The fourth area covers behavioral factors, such as antibiotic use practices and public awareness of related risks. The fifth area is dedicated to assessing the AMR burden, including morbidity, mortality, treatment costs, and socio-economic consequences.

To implement this approach, CAREC proposed strengthening cooperation between national institutions, technical working groups, and the Regional Secretariat of the 'One Health' programme. The proposal does not involve creating parallel structures but instead focuses on unifying research methods, knowledge exchange, and supporting existing national surveillance systems. For Uzbekistan, integrating water resource monitoring with AMR surveillance can become an additional tool for preventing risks to public health, agriculture, and the environment; however, assessing the scale of these risks within the country requires national research and systematic monitoring.

Similar stories

Central Asia Needs a Coordinated Antimicrobial Resistance Monitoring System
Read more
uzdaily.uz

Central Asia Needs a Coordinated Antimicrobial Resistance Monitoring System

Central Asian countries must establish a harmonized surveillance system for antimicrobial resistance (AMR) that integrates data from healthcare, veterinary, environmental research, and climate monitoring. Despite the growing global threat of antibiotic resistance, the lack of comparable regional data hinders the assessment of the problem's scale and the identification of pathways for the spread of resistant microorganisms.

This was stated by Oksana Kravtsova, project coordinator at the Central Asia Regional Environmental Centre (CAREC), during an international conference on antimicrobial resistance held in Astana on November 19–20. In her presentation titled 'Climate Change as a Factor Contributing to Antimicrobial Resistance,' Kravtsova examined ecological mechanisms affecting the spread of antibiotic resistance, gaps in regional surveillance systems, and opportunities for cross-border cooperation under the 'One Health' approach.

According to Kravtsova, combating antibiotic resistance requires a comprehensive approach because resistant microorganisms and resistance genes can circulate among humans, animals, and in the environment.

Antimicrobial Resistance: 1.14 Million Deaths Per Year

Kravtsova cited data from the Global Burden of Disease 2021 study, published in the scientific journal The Lancet in 2024. According to this study, bacterial antimicrobial resistance was directly responsible for approximately 1.14 million deaths worldwide in 2021, with another 4.71 million deaths linked to bacterial AMR.

It is important to distinguish these figures: the first reflects deaths directly related to bacterial resistance, while the second covers a broader category of deaths caused by infections triggered by resistant pathogens. Under the baseline projection scenario, antimicrobial resistance could lead to cumulative 39.1 million deaths between 2025 and 2050.

Kravtsova emphasized the need to separate global estimates from regional indicators, as the figures presented reflect the global AMR burden but do not establish corresponding mortality rates in Central Asian countries. One of the main obstacles to making such assessments is the shortage of comparable data collected by medical, veterinary, and environmental institutions.

Water Temperature and Transmission of Resistance Genes

Kravtsova also addressed the potential influence of climate-related factors on the spread of resistant microorganisms. She referred to a study published in the Journal of Hazardous Materials in 2024. A laboratory experiment established that increasing water temperature from 5°C to 30°C is associated with an approximate 30-fold increase in the frequency of antibiotic resistance gene transfer.

This finding indicates that temperature conditions can significantly affect the horizontal transfer of resistance genes between bacteria. However, Kravtsova stressed the limitations of interpreting such experimental results. The observed increase applies to a specific laboratory system and does not imply a comparable rise in morbidity, mortality, or prevalence of resistant bacteria in the natural ecosystems of Central Asia.

She also noted that temperature is not the only factor contributing to antimicrobial resistance; important determinants remain antibiotic use, sanitation conditions, and access to healthcare.

Four Categories of Data for Integrated Surveillance

Kravtsova identified the fragmentation of information collected by various state agencies and institutions as one of the central problems of regional AMR surveillance. To form a comprehensive understanding of the issue, at least four categories of data must be integrated.

Healthcare Data

These include laboratory results for resistant pathogens, antibiotic prescribing practices, patient diagnoses, and treatment outcomes.

Veterinary Data

This data covers the use of antibiotics in livestock farming and the results of monitoring resistant microorganisms in animals.

Environmental Data

This helps track the presence of bacteria and antibiotic resistance genes in municipal and hospital wastewater, surface waters, and soils.

Climate Data

This includes information on temperature, precipitation, floods, and hydrological conditions that may affect the environmental spread of microorganisms.

According to a CAREC representative, effective integration of these datasets requires harmonized indicators, data quality standards, information exchange procedures, and common analytical approaches. Without such coordination, an increase in individual studies will not necessarily provide a complete picture of the spread of antibiotic resistance in the region.

Six Potential Environmental Pathways for Resistance

In her speech, Kravtsova named six types of natural and anthropogenic environments that can contribute to the accumulation and circulation of resistant microorganisms and resistance genes. These include municipal and hospital wastewater, rivers and other bodies of water, livestock systems, agricultural soils, wildlife, as well as glaciers and meltwater.

Transboundary water systems are particularly important for Central Asia. Kravtsova highlighted three main river systems—the Amu Darya, Syr Darya, and Ili—that connect territories of several countries. Potential environmental risks can arise from insufficiently treated wastewater discharges, runoff from agricultural and livestock areas, and changes in water use practices during droughts.

Floods and heavy rains can facilitate the movement of pollutants into surface waters. In conditions of water scarcity, the importance of sanitary protection measures and water purification quality increases, especially where water reuse occurs. Nevertheless, the existence of these environmental pathways does not confirm that transboundary spread of resistant bacteria has already been recorded in each of the mentioned river systems; specialized studies are required to determine the scale and direction of such movement.

Five Research Priorities for Central Asia

Kravtsova outlined five research priorities necessary for a deeper understanding of antimicrobial resistance in the region. The first priority concerns seasonal correlations between temperature, flooding, and antimicrobial resistance indicators. The second involves studying the movement of resistant bacteria and resistance genes through water, soil, livestock systems, and interaction with human populations.

The third priority calls for comparing microorganisms isolated from clinical samples, animals, and environmental sources, which can help identify possible links between different reservoirs of resistance. The fourth priority relates to behavioral factors, including antibiotic use practices and risk communication. The fifth priority is assessing the burden of antimicrobial resistance, including its impact on morbidity, mortality, treatment costs, and broader socio-economic consequences.

Advancing these research directions will require not only expanding laboratory investigations but also harmonizing methodologies across countries.

How Regional Cooperation Can Be Organized

Discussing possibilities for regional interaction, Kravtsova presented a model that includes four levels of coordination: the Regional Council, technical working groups, the Regional Secretariat, and national institutions. The Regional Council will promote the alignment of priorities among participating countries and government bodies. Technical working groups can provide scientific expertise, develop harmonized laboratory approaches, and organize joint events.

The Regional Secretariat will support cross-border dialogue, knowledge exchange, and the development of common cooperation procedures. National institutions will retain responsibility for data collection, epidemiological surveillance, response measures, and implementation. In Kravtsova's view, regional coordination should strengthen existing national systems, not replace them or create parallel administrative structures. The main focus, therefore, is on ensuring the compatibility of national surveillance systems and their ability to work together, rather than creating a separate supranational management system.

Significance for Uzbekistan

For Uzbekistan, the development of integrated surveillance is particularly relevant, given the country's dependence on transboundary water resources, the scale of irrigated agriculture, and the need to control antibiotic use in healthcare and animal husbandry. Data from medical laboratories, veterinary services, environmental monitoring, and hydrological observations can be analyzed together to identify possible links between antimicrobial resistance and environmental changes.

Risk assessment in the Amu Darya and Syr Darya basins will require not only national research but also comparable monitoring data from neighboring countries. Such cooperation is becoming increasingly important in the context of climate change. Rising temperatures, droughts, extreme rainfall, and floods can alter the survival and spread conditions of microorganisms. However, the extent of the influence of these factors on antimicrobial resistance in Central Asia is yet to be determined.

The approaches proposed by CAREC call for moving beyond isolated laboratory studies and fragmented institutional surveillance towards coordinated data analysis. This can help countries more accurately assess risks, define prevention priorities, and develop joint measures to combat antimicrobial resistance.

Climate change may accelerate the spread of antibiotic resistance in Central Asia
Read more
uzdaily.uz

Climate change may accelerate the spread of antibiotic resistance in Central Asia

Climate change potentially could contribute to the spread of antibiotic resistance in the Central Asian region. Rising temperatures, floods, and water scarcity can affect the movement of resistant microorganisms, as well as the dissemination of antibiotic resistance genes in the environment.

These risks were voiced by Oksana Kravtsova, a representative of the Central Asia Regional Environmental Centre (CAREC), during an international conference held in Astana on November 19. According to the information presented, climate changes can impact both the survival and spread of microorganisms and the transmission of resistance genes between bacteria.

One of the mechanisms under consideration is horizontal gene transfer—the process of exchanging genetic material associated with antimicrobial resistance between bacteria. The presentation refers to the results of a laboratory study published in the Journal of Hazardous Materials in 2024. In the experiment, increasing the water temperature from 5°C to 30°C led to an approximately 30-fold increase in the frequency of antibiotic resistance gene transfer.

However, the authors emphasize that these data pertain to a specific experimental system and do not imply a comparable increase in antimicrobial resistance, morbidity, or mortality in natural ecosystems of Central Asia.

In addition to rising temperatures, extreme weather events can play a significant role. Floods and heavy rains can carry pollutants from agricultural areas and livestock farms into surface waters, potentially increasing human and animal contact with resistant microorganisms. In turn, droughts and water shortages can alter water reuse practices, increasing the need for effective sanitation and water purification.

Dust storms are also a potential factor, as they can transport microbial material, but their contribution to the spread of antibiotic resistance genes in Central Asia requires further study.

For Uzbekistan, these issues are particularly relevant due to rising temperatures, water scarcity, irrigated agriculture, and intensive livestock farming. It is noted, however, that climate change is not the sole or necessarily primary cause of antibiotic resistance; the main factors remain the use of antibiotics in human and veterinary medicine, sanitary conditions, access to treatment, and the effectiveness of epidemiological surveillance systems.

Within the 'One Health' approach, experts advocate for considering human, animal, and environmental health as interconnected elements of a single system. This approach involves integrating clinical, veterinary, ecological, and climatic data to improve risk assessment and develop preventive measures. For Central Asia, one of the priority areas for future research may be studying seasonal links between temperature, extreme weather events, and the spread of resistant microorganisms. Such studies will help determine which specific climatic factors influence antibiotic resistance in regional conditions and what adaptive measures can mitigate potential risks.

Dr. Randip Guleria warns of critical air pollution levels in Delhi threatening health
Read more
www.aajtak.in

Dr. Randip Guleria warns of critical air pollution levels in Delhi threatening health

Following Diwali, the air pollution crisis in Delhi has reached a dangerous point, as pollution levels have risen to their lowest recorded level in recent days. An AQI of 1331 was recorded in Delhi, and the impact of toxic particles in the air has begun to affect people's health. Due to the pollution, the number of patients with respiratory problems may increase in the near future, and there is a risk of death for people with existing serious illnesses.

In an interview with India Today Digital, Dr. Randip Guleria, a senior pulmonologist and former director of AIIMS, described the rising pollution as a medical emergency. Dr. Guleria explained that PM2.5 and other harmful pollutants present in the air enter the body through breathing and harm health. The situation becomes extremely serious when pollution levels are so high that standard air quality sensors cannot properly register them.

The greatest danger threatens those suffering from asthma, COPD, or heart diseases. Such patients may suddenly experience worsening symptoms such as shortness of breath, chest tightness, and coughing. In severe cases, oxygen levels can drop, requiring hospitalization.

Dr. Guleria suggested that due to increased pollution, the number of patients seeking care at clinics and hospital emergency departments could increase by 20–30% in the coming days. He noted that the effect of pollution is not immediate but gradual, and there can be a delay of four to six days between the increase in hospital patients and the actual event. Dr. Guleria reminded that last year, many patients sought hospital treatment for respiratory problems; some required stays in wards and intensive care units, and in severe cases, mechanical ventilation.

Even healthy individuals can face unpleasant consequences from pollution. Living in heavily polluted air can cause a healthy person to experience coughing, throat irritation, chest heaviness, and difficulty breathing. Therefore, everyone needs to pay attention to their health right now.

According to Dr. Guleria, he has received reports from many patients complaining of worsening respiratory problems. Some require nebulizers, while others, upon doctor's recommendation, must take short courses of steroids.

Elderly people, young children, and those suffering from asthma, COPD, and heart disease should exercise extra caution. During heavy pollution, outdoor exposure should be avoided. If going out is necessary, a well-fitting N95 mask should be used. It is essential to take prescribed medications and inhalers regularly.

It is necessary to seek hospital care if you experience the following symptoms: shortness of breath, chest pain, persistent cough, or decreased oxygen levels.

Popular