Washington issues first deep-sea mining licenses in the Pacific despite unfavorable court ruling
Read more
Noticias ao Minuto
noticiasaominuto.com

Washington issues first deep-sea mining licenses in the Pacific despite unfavorable court ruling

The U.S. government announced on Thursday the issuance of its first deep-sea mineral exploration licenses in waters adjacent to its territories in the Pacific, even after an unfavorable court decision was issued earlier this week.

These two licenses cover a vast area of over 125 thousand square kilometers, exceeding the area of Portugal's continental shelf and islands. The area is near American Samoa, a territory under Washington's jurisdiction in the southwest Pacific.

Doug Burgum, the American secretary responsible for the sector, stated in a press release that this is a historic moment for U.S. mineral and energy security, as it marks the first time the country has organized the sale of licenses for critical mineral exploration in the deep sea in the Pacific.

The two licenses were auctioned for a total amount of 6 million dollars (equivalent to 5.5 million euros) to companies whose identities have not been disclosed.

This authorization occurs in a context of support from the emerging industry, which has been subject to various criticisms, driven by Donald Trump.

In April 2025, the American President had issued a decree aimed at facilitating seabed mining, which represented a challenge to the competence of the International Seabed Authority (ISA), the body theoretically responsible for regulating such activities in the deep sea. This initiative generated criticism from various sectors, including environmental groups and the Chinese government.

According to Secretary Doug Burgum, the decision made on Thursday will allow for obtaining more data on available resources near the coast of American Samoa and assessing their potential to ensure a more stable national supply.

The seabed is highly sought after due to the abundance of sought-after minerals, essential in the production of devices such as smartphones, laptops, solar panels, and electric vehicles.

However, scientists warn of the environmental risks inherent in mining, and dozens of nations advocate for the implementation of a moratorium.

In American Samoa itself, local authorities had vetoed the exploitation of the ocean subsurface in waters under its sovereignty in 2024. However, the federal government has authority over the outer zone of the continental shelf covered by the new licenses.

On Monday, a federal judge in Hawaii, prompted by opponents, ruled that the government violated the law during the licensing process. The magistrate observed that the responsible federal agency 'did not even attempt to consider the potential effects' of the project on protected fauna and flora species.

The region in question is located near the Rose Atoll marine reserve and hosts several protected species, such as turtles, sharks, whales, and corals.

Despite the judicial determination, the granting of these licenses is considered a 'rebellious and illegal act' by a lawyer from the environmental organization Earthjustice, who promised to mobilize all means to annul these permits.

Similar stories

Norwegian Supreme Court annuls three North Sea oil licenses due to flaws in environmental studies
Read more
noticiasaominuto.com

Norwegian Supreme Court annuls three North Sea oil licenses due to flaws in environmental studies

Norway's highest court has ruled to annul three oil exploration licenses located in the North Sea. This decision resulted from challenges brought by two environmental organizations, which pointed out the inadequacy of the environmental impact studies conducted.

The Supreme Court, by upholding the determinations of lower judicial instances, established that any emissions generated by burning extracted oil must undergo an impact assessment before the Norwegian state can grant exploration permits.

To reach this verdict, the court utilized a panel of 11 judges, exceeding the usual number of five, a procedure reserved for cases of great importance in Norway. In its statement, the Supreme Court informed that the majority of six magistrates considered both the studies and the assessments conducted by the competent authorities to be insufficient.

However, the Court clarified that this annulment does not imply the automatic loss of validity of the authorizations for the holders of the exploration rights. The responsibility to reevaluate these licenses now falls on the Norwegian Ministry of Energy.

Various legal experts and NGOs questioning the granting of exploration concessions to oil and gas companies will analyze the scope of this decision, given that this type of dispute has gained global prominence.

The organizations Natur og Ungdom (Nature and Youth) and the Norwegian section of Greenpeace initiated legal action in 2023 against the authorizations granted to the Tyrving, Breidablikk, and Yggdrasil reserves, arguing that they were issued without proper environmental impact studies.

A first-instance court ruled in favor of the entities in January 2024, leading the Norwegian Ministry of Energy to file an appeal. Subsequently, this judgment was confirmed by an appellate court in November 2025.

Since the invasion of Ukraine by Russia, which occurred in 2014 and again in 2022, Norway has consolidated its position as a major exporter of gas and oil in Western Europe, maintaining its intention to expand its sector.

Haldis Tjeldflaat Helle, representative of the Norwegian Greenpeace delegation, one of the parties bringing the complaint, told Agence France Presse that the case represented a 'historic victory for the climate.' She added that 'major polluters are now obliged to accurately admit the extent to which they contribute to the climate crisis we are currently experiencing.'

Following the release of the judicial ruling, the Ministry of Energy, the body that had granted the licenses, opted not to issue any comment.

Popular