Supreme Court rules that courts cannot demand repayment from homebuyers without verifying links between banks and developers
Read more
The times of India
timesofindia.indiatimes.com

Supreme Court rules that courts cannot demand repayment from homebuyers without verifying links between banks and developers

The Supreme Court (SC) has issued a decision that provides significant relief to hundreds of thousands of homebuyers. The Court ruled that in cases where housing projects remain incomplete, even if banks have paid substantial portions of loan installments to unscrupulous or insolvent developers, commercial courts, NCLT, or NCLAT do not have the authority to demand reimbursement from apartment buyers to financiers before investigating any 'improper' connection between the banks and the developers.

This ruling was delivered by a bench comprising Chief Justice Surya Kant, along with Justices Joymalya Bagchi and Vin Mohan. It was made at the request of homebuyers in the Krishna Housing project in Gurgaon, which was being developed by Raheja Developers and subsequently entered insolvency proceedings.

The plaintiffs alleged that a bank had initiated legal action to recover funds against them in a commercial court in Saket, New Delhi, despite them not yet having received their apartments. The bench, led by the Chief Justice, stated that the commercial court's duty is to establish the relationship between the developer and the bank's employees, as well as to verify whether the loan was disbursed strictly in accordance with the tripartite agreement.

The Court emphasized that unless a definitive conclusion is reached that the homebuyers are in default of obligations, no interim orders regarding installment payments can be issued. The civil court was directed not to take any coercive action against the plaintiffs or similarly situated persons until the aforementioned issue is clarified.

According to the tripartite agreement among the buyers, the developer, and the banks, the financier was supposed to transfer the loan amount directly to the developer proportionate to the construction progress on the site. However, in many instances, due to connections between the developer's staff and the banks, financial institutions disbursed loan amounts to each buyer significantly higher than what should have been allocated to the developer, considering the stage of the housing project's construction.

When a project remained unfinished for decades, the bank filed recovery suits against homebuyers who continued to pay monthly installments (EMI) and rent without receiving their apartments. Issuing a judgment in such a suit would impose a heavy financial burden on the homebuyers.

Last September, the bench, under Justice Kant, ordered a CBI investigation into numerous developers and banks across India for collusion aimed at the improper use of the tripartite subsidy scheme and defrauding homebuyers, even when projects remained incomplete for decades.

The bench noted that its sympathy for homebuyers had effectively opened the floodgates for litigation, leading thousands of victims of developer and bank tyranny to approach the Supreme Court directly. The Court stated that 'our hands are overloaded, and we may not be able to handle a new lawsuit.'

In a similar case from Bengaluru involving over 4,000 homebuyers, the court protected the buyers from potential lawsuits by banks because the housing project had remained incomplete for nearly ten years, despite the plaintiffs having paid 95% of the apartment's cost. After providing protection, the bench advised the plaintiff's lawyer to seek appropriate assistance from the High Court of Karnataka.

Similar stories

Supreme Court notes that people tend to violate air pollution control restrictions
Read more
timesofindia.indiatimes.com

Supreme Court notes that people tend to violate air pollution control restrictions

The Supreme Court stated that attempts to solve the air pollution problem in Delhi, despite significant judicial efforts, have only led to marginal improvement because people tend to violate the imposed restrictions with greater force.

The judicial bench, which included Chief Justice Surya Kant, along with judges Joymalya Bagchi and Vi Mohan, analyzed numerous orders and subsequent monitoring of their implementation aimed at improving air quality. The judges noted that achieving a clean air level below 100 (AQI) during the winter in Delhi is a utopian goal, as 'very poor' and 'severe' conditions have become the new norm.

When amicus curiae advocate and senior counsel Aparajit Singh drew the court's attention to the spread of news about selling regular firecrackers as 'green crackers' and linked the rise in pollution to this phenomenon, the bench noted that there had been severe traffic congestion in the capital in recent days. The presence of a large number of vehicles on the roads for extended periods likely increases the pollution load.

Additional General Advisor Aishwarya Bati explained the traffic jams due to the festive season, while senior counsel Sanjeev Sen, representing MCD, pointed out that the culture of gift-giving has become one of the main reasons for the sharp increase in road traffic.

At this point, Singh brought to the court's attention that selling regular firecrackers under the guise of 'green crackers' is a gross violation of judicial directives, warning of a possible sharp rise in pollution levels after Diwali.

The bench emphasized that Diwali celebrations must be accompanied by public awareness campaigns, as awareness is what can stop pollution. It was noted that no amount of restrictions will help, and the more court orders there are, the more violations occur, which is a human tendency. The court decided to follow expert advice.

The Chief Justice stated that local councilors must conduct awareness work among the population. The bench reported the adoption of certain orders and requested compliance in the NCR states.

Bati informed the court that the Commission for Air Quality Management (CAQM), an expert body responsible for developing and implementing short-term, medium-term, and long-term measures to combat air pollution, has introduced the Graded Response Action Plan (GRAP). She explained that each stage of GRAP activates additional restrictions, such as halting construction, banning entry of BS-IV standard vehicles, water spraying, and phased changes in office working hours. Furthermore, the number of public transport using clean fuel has been significantly increased. However, Bati added that all human activities contribute to pollution, noting that factories in Delhi operate on clean fuel, and thermal power plants have been closed.

She indicated that the main pollution load comes from vehicles, given the huge number of them in Delhi. The Additional General Advisor stated that the primary sources of pollution in Delhi are vehicles and other local sources. Stubble burning in winter, which has sharply decreased in Haryana and to some extent in Punjab, exacerbates the situation due to Delhi's unique geographical location and wind direction, making the national capital a recipient of pollution.

Singh stressed the importance of monitoring the implementation of anti-pollution measures and complained that vehicles continue to idle at MCD toll plazas at 126 entry points. Sen refuted this claim, stating that after integrating technology, no vehicle idles at any of the nine toll plazas serving 90% of commercial traffic in Delhi.

Popular